After you cast all day where do you feel sore? That would be a good place to start deciding which ones you use.
I am no certified caster nor am I ATC (certified trainer) but I think I can help you a bit.
As I am learning more about the proper casting techniques I am finding the following, in regards to your question;
forearm strength to keep a good grip and keep control of your wrist
bicep to pull the rod to you for the back cast
tricep to push the rod away from you on the forward cast
shoulder muscles to keep control of your arm and allow for the slightly upward rotation of the arm, and downward rotation on the forward cast.
You may notice some discomfort deep in your shoulder after a long day of casting and those little guys would be your rotator cuff, all four of the little muscles surrounding your shoulder.
The more you cast the stronger they will get, but do not keep casting or throwing once they start burning and letting you know they need a break. Give them a break and let them build up, remember they are small muscles and you do not want to miss fishing time because of a surgery on them.
Again, I am not a doctor or certified caster but I did sleep in a Holiday Inn Express last night. I hope this helps
